風格與我們喜歡的東西有關係嗎?


3

許多人說,體裁和子體裁的主要目的之一是識別我們個人喜歡聽到的東西和我們不喜歡聽到的東西。以下是我聽過的藝術家的一小部分:

WindirLinkin ParkNirvanaAdeleEminemDeathFranz FerdinandGreen Day(已鏈接:新專輯中唯一可挽救的歌曲:)),Johnny CashRadioheadLinkin Park0和Linkin Park1。

如果單擊每個鏈接,您將看到它們之間的區別。我的意思是,當然,其中很多都受岩石的影響,但是這裡有很多不同的子流派和風格。因此,如果我喜歡《極樂世界》,我是否喜歡《愛麗絲鎖鏈》?哎呀,我願意!由於我喜歡Linkin Park,所以我必須喜歡Korn。嗯,不?

我的問題是,欣賞一首甚至可以被最具體的(命名)子流派歸類的歌曲是否會增加某人欣賞該子流派另一首歌的機會?

瓦爾法爾(Windir的已故歌手)在他的家鄉挪威鬆達爾(Sogndal)後稱他的音樂 Sognametal 。多年來,它已經囊括了其他幾支挪威樂隊,它們的聲音相似,其中大多數是由Windir以前的成員創立的。因此,如果我喜歡Windir,就必須喜歡其他Sognametal樂隊,對嗎?畢竟,它們的聲音幾乎與Windir的聲音相同!不。我聽過的其他" Sognametal"樂隊都無法像Windir那樣引起我的共鳴。

那麼,你們都怎麼想?我會喜歡泰勒·斯威夫特,因為我喜歡阿黛爾嗎,有可能更有可能嗎?(提示:我真的不知道)。

任何想法都感激!

2

A genre is defined by a set of stylistic similarities and it's logical that someone who likes one artist/band of a genre will be more likely to like another artist from the same genre. But although the correlation is probably high, there are plenty of reasons that a listener might not like a similar band. Maybe the band plays badly, or the singer has an unpleasant voice, or the guitarist plays boring solos, or the texts are uninteresting, or the sound is badly mixed, or whatever. So even though it's likely you'll like something similar, there's no guarantee. Music tastes are just too subjective.
The algorithms of streaming services like Spotify work this way. If you like one song, the service suggests other songs that are similar.
So, to answer your question: there is probably a significant overlap between Taylor Swift and Adele fans (and probably only a small group of hard-core fans of each of them who hate the other one just because they're not their idol).
Unfortunately I don't know of any studies which would substantiate this.


2

Like @PiedPiper said, music is too subjective. I just wanted to add that it is possible to like a song of a certain genre without necessarily enjoying that genre. For example, Cupid Shuffle. I know lots of people that don't even listen to that kind of music, but LOVE that song.